2025/06/24
Why Security Deposits May Not Be Returned — Key Reasons and Proactive Measures in Rental Market

In the luxury rental sector, it is not uncommon for tenants to express concerns such as, “My security deposit wasn’t fully returned,” or “I was surprised by the amount deducted.” A security deposit is, by definition, a financial safeguard entrusted to the landlord to cover potential rent arrears or the cost of restoring the property to its original condition. At the end of the lease, the standard practice is for the landlord to deduct legitimate charges—such as unpaid rent or repair costs—and return the remaining balance to the tenant. However, in reality, the process is not always seamless. There are several reasons why security deposits may not be refunded in full, many of which can be anticipated and mitigated through careful planning and contractual awareness.

One common cause is the stipulation of mandatory cleaning fees within the lease agreement. Even if the tenant believes the property was kept in good condition, a clause requiring a standard house cleaning fee upon move-out allows the landlord to lawfully deduct the amount from the deposit. In recent years, it has become increasingly standard for such fees to be automatically subtracted from the security deposit, provided this is clearly stated in the lease. Tenant are expected to be fully informed of such terms at the time of signing.

Another frequent source of deductions involves costs associated with restoring the property due to damage caused by the tenant’s negligence or misuse. This includes items such as holes in walls, nicotine stains on wallpaper, deep scratches on hardwood floors, or broken fixtures. Conversely, wear and tear resulting from ordinary usage or the natural aging of materials is generally not the tenant’s responsibility. The ambiguity in distinguishing “ordinary wear” from “tenant-caused damage,” however, often lies at the heart of disputes. For instance, marks left by furniture or mold caused by condensation behind a refrigerator may be interpreted differently by each party, leading to disagreements over liability.

Furthermore, any outstanding rent or unpaid maintenance fees will, quite naturally, be deducted from the security deposit. It is essential to confirm whether rent for the final month has been properly prorated and whether all utility bills have been settled. In many cases where the refunded amount is zero—or even results in an additional balance owed—these unpaid items and supplemental charges are key contributing factors.

To avoid such issues, several proactive measures can be highly effective. First and foremost, prospective tenants should thoroughly review the terms of the lease before moving in. A clear understanding of how the security deposit is defined, whether cleaning fees are applicable, and the standards for property restoration is crucial. Special attention must be paid to any “special clauses”, as these carry significant legal weight and should never be overlooked.

Secondly, documenting the condition of the property both at the time of move-in and move-out is a wise precaution. Taking photographs or videos to visually record the state of the premises—particularly the walls, flooring, and fixtures—can provide objective evidence in the event of a dispute. Focusing on areas prone to wear or damage can greatly enhance the credibility of any claims made after vacating the property.

Additionally, a thorough cleaning prior to move-out, along with minor repairs where feasible, can help prevent excessive deductions for restoration costs. Small efforts—such as removing mildew with common cleaning agents or tightening loose screws—may go a long way in minimizing avoidable expenses.

If there is dissatisfaction with the amount refunded, tenants are advised to first request a detailed breakdown from the property management company. Should the explanation be vague or unsatisfactory, seeking assistance from a neutral body, such as a consumer affairs center, may be appropriate. As security deposit disputes are prevalent across the country, a wealth of legal precedents and official guidelines exist to support tenants in handling such matters with clarity and composure.

When a security deposit is not returned, it often leaves more than just a financial burden—it can also lead to lingering frustration for the tenant. However, most such situations can be prevented through clear understanding of the lease and meticulous handling of the move-out process. Moving out not only marks the beginning of a new chapter, but also a respectful close to the previous one. Being well-prepared in matters related to the security deposit ensures that this transition is both smooth and dignified.